Here are Round 1 reviews and rankings from Leonie Connellan of Hot Pink Halo:
--
Judging this was hard. I changed my top ten alone somewhere in the realm of 20 times. I genuinely enjoyed aspects of every song, even the ones near the bottom of my list. As always with reviews, everybody is going to have a different perspective, and I hope mine is helpful. For the record, I listened to all the songs at least five times. Probably more. My order of importance when judging is, generally: song / structure > lyrics > emotional core / storytelling / intention > musical ability > production skills. Obviously all of those things cross over to a degree, and sometimes I’ll focus more on one aspect or another. As always, take what you can use from my feedback, and leave what you can’t.
Matt Rhog-Miller - Retail Therapy This sounds like it’s recorded in one take with you playing guitar and singing at the same time. If your recording setup allows for it, it might be beneficial for you to record the instruments and vocals separately. Your vocals sound a little too tied to the rhythm of the guitar playing at first, and are a touch stilted as a result. There are some awkward spots where you take a breath in the middle of a sentence, and if you’re able to do a few vocal takes you could plan out the breathing better which would improve the flow. During the first verse in particular you sound quite nervous and tense, but that said, you seem to relax more as the song progresses, and those issues that I’ve mentioned become less apparent. If you are only able to record everything in a single take, you might consider at least doing a few runs in a row and I think that you’d end up with something that sounds really good.
Stacking Theory - This Pale Blue Dot “Riots at the top of town” is a helluva way to open a song. Luckily for you I also understand the exact context, and can picture the particular “top of town” you’re referencing very well in my mind’s eye. Even though this is about very specific events, I feel like you’ve managed to generalise enough that people less familiar with the situation will understand what’s going on, but it will be interesting to read the reactions. Out of all the songs this one stands out the most as stylistically different to me, and I think you made some really good choices with panning and those ethereal background sounds (traffic? trucks?) and lonely keyboards to set the scene for space, and reinforce the idea of drifting through time. My one criticism of this song would be that it’s SO nihilistic, which is the antithesis of Carl Sagan. Like, even though his Pale Blue Dot piece goes into all the heartbreak and the pointless power struggles and the fleetingness of it all, it’s never nihilistic because he was a relentless optimist. If you wanted to adjust that sentiment just slightly, I think you could do it just by tweaking the word “stain” to something else. I don’t know what that word would be, but I personally would look for something a bit more neutral. The last line where the vocals become robotic then drift away is perfect. This is one of your best songs, and I really do promise that it’s not even the twelve jars of Vegemite talking.
Daniel Sitler - Only (Kind of) Blue 
This is one of those songs where I enjoyed it before looking at any of the background  information or lyrics, then appreciated it even more after learning the back story. I think it’s  commendable to write a song about an ex without demonising anyone. It’s sentimental without  being self-indulgent, which is a hard thing to pull off. The knowledge that you developed the  music from an existing piece is pretty cool and clever. I liked it before I knew that, but I enjoyed it even more after. Adding my own reading to some of the lyrics: it’s interesting that you go to  Red in the bridge. That could be because red is a colour associated with anger and rashness,  but I immediately read it as a “red shift” / “blue shift” kind of affair, as in the Doppler shifts of  light, with the redshift moving away into the past and the blueshift accelerating toward the  future. This marries nicely with the reference to motion and speed in “we were dancing to Kind  of Blue, but I couldn’t keep up with you”. In the lines “I never could have seen through, I never  could have seen it through”, you’ve changed the entire meaning of the sentence just by adding  a single two-letter word, which is some kind of magic trick. The minimalistic instrumentation  reinforces the intimacy of the tune, and there’s really nothing I would even consider changing  there. The doubling of the vocals in the choruses and bridge is a good way to open the song up  and differentiate it from the verses. Overall, this is a really personal song but you’ve managed to  be just broad enough in your language and performance that we can bring our own meanings to  it. This is a song that really rewards repeated listens and I think I just convinced myself to move  it to the top of the list. Well done. 
See-Man-Ski - Pulp 
Your sound is very distinctively you. My first listen through I deliberately didn’t look at names  and titles, and I immediately knew who made this one. I love the big build up in the verse  followed by the way you drop everything back to a very subdued first couple of lines in the  chorus. All the little vocal flourishes to extend out word and add emphasis are super fun and  enjoyable. I know you’re all like, “This a a song just about orange juice! No deeper meaning at  all!”, but I can spot the fine tradition of double entendre in song from a mile away, and I strongly  approve. Unrelated to your song, but something I keep thinking of when I listen to it, is the book  Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine by Gail Honeyman. Eleanor discovers Tesco’s “Orange  Juice with Bits” thanks to a musician*, and it makes me laugh every time I see it at Tesco now. I  also prefer my Orange Juice with “Bits”.  
*”I had arranged to have the afternoon off that day for my appointment at the hairdressers, but  ate my lunch in the staff room first as usual, with the Telegraph crossword, a tuna and sweet  corn bloomer, salt and vinegar crisps and orange juice, with bits. I must thank the musician, in  due course, for introducing me to the pleasure of bits.” 
The Dutch Widows - Pastel Purple Icing What a mystery. These lyrics are super-opaque, but also incredibly intriguing, and I personally really enjoy the process of trying to figure it out but really having no effing clue. I’ve been looking up all sorts of British cakes and can find nothing specific about pale purple icing, so can only assume that it’s either about a very personal memory, or that the entire song is made from metaphor. It didn’t help that I originally misheard “pastel purple icing and buttercream” as “pastel purple icing and verdigris”, and thought that this was a song that referenced two colours. I spent several minutes searching for information about cakes iced in purple and green before thinking to look at the actual lyrics.
The tale that I’ve managed to spin myself about this song is that it’s somehow about Harry and Meghan leaving royal life behind, because I think the Queen’s Birthday holiday is celebrated in June, and purple has traditionally been a colour reserved for royalty.
Whatever it’s about, the picture painted is about someone stuck in a mental loop, and I enjoy  the reflection of that in the way the music has been constructed. 
Chas Rock - Hazel Green 
The style of the music here has a pleasant 60s vibe, although the melody feels almost a little too  familiar. I can’t quite put my finger on what it’s reminding me of, but it’s enjoyable nonetheless. I  think you’ve layered three different drum tracks panned left, right and centre, which is slightly  unusual but creates some interesting and cool polyrhythm and spatial effects. The higher  pitched harmony on “morning” adds some good flavour. The link to the challenge is a little  tenuous, but I do specifically think of “hazel green” as an eye colour before anything else. 
Timothy Patrick Hinkle - Slate 
This is an interesting one in that I get a lot more out of listening to you sing the lyrics than I do  from reading them on the page. Written down they seem very flowery and almost impenetrable,  but hearing them sung is easy and very evocative. The line that hit home the hardest is “every  day the ache inside expands to fill the space”. I think a lot of the magic in this one hangs on your  vocal delivery, which is very, very good. It’s also a double-edged sword, because that delivery  has to be spot on every time for the song to work. There’s the danger that it will just become a  jumble of words and meaningless metaphors otherwise. 
Ominous Ride - Gin Black Days One of the most useful things that I learned though critiques at art school is to never apologise for what you’ve made before anyone’s had the chance to make up their own mind. Just because you’re disappointed in your work, that doesn’t mean that other people will be. If your audience do pick up on the same things that you feel unhappy with in your song, then that’s a good indication that, yeah, those parts are things you might want to work on. If not, then nobody ever needs to know, and it might just be an indication that you’re better at something than you think you are. (I hope that most of the other contestants also read the different reviews, because this is a piece of advice that could apply to almost everyone taking part.)
To the song though, I don’t think this is too short, and I don’t think it needs another verse for the sake of it. Oftentimes a shorter song is a better song. I’d rather be left wanting more than having something that outstays its welcome.
Those higher harmonies sound really good to me and add a lot. Overall though, your vocals are quite clear and distinct, but somehow they just wash over me without really sticking. I had to read the lyrics to really get a grasp on the subject matter, even with knowing the title or hearing that cool glass crashing sample at the end of the song. I’m not sure if that’s an issue with too many sounds sitting in the same frequency range, or maybe just some genre bias sneaking in on my part, so do take that critique with a grain of salt; it will be interesting to hear if anyone else shares that opinion, or if it’s just me.
Governing Dynamics - violetlies
This song is just absolutely begging for some kind of string arrangement. I’d build it up slowly,  starting underneath at 2:19, then really let it loose at somewhere around 3:35. As it is, the  performances and production are pretty rough around the edges; you stumble over some words  here and there, and don’t always hit what you’re going for, but I don’t really care because the  song itself has a lot of potential. It’s the one I’ve had stuck in my head for the longest, and of all  the songs, it’s the one that I think could be performed in a lot of different ways and have a  fantastic impact each time. I really like a lot of the lyrics, especially “In the silence of your violet  skied violence, not so much magic as tragic contrivance” and “dust and pollution diffusing the  light, such ugly truths and beautiful violent lies”. It’s very evocative and I really enjoyed it. I think  if you spend some time really planning it out and polishing it, it will be well worth your while. 
Sara Parsons - Secondary 
There’s something about the sparseness of the instrumentation and vocals here that really  makes this song shine. The lyrics themselves border on cliché, but the vocal delivery is so  masterful that you manage to sell them. I do really like the main idea of primary colours mixing  to secondary. The way you break up “Tee — eee —- eeth” is utterly charming, and there are a  lot of other small touches along those lines that make the whole song and performance really  personable, even the little chord clash under “green iced tea”. The length is spot on, and it  doesn’t outstay its welcome. I listened to all the songs multiple times in different environments,  and when I was listening to this one without any other distractions, it somehow managed to  make me cry. Twice. I’m super glad you signed up and look forward to hearing your other songs! 
Entertainment Brothers - Purple I was pretty glad to hear another blues in the mix, and to be honest I’m amazed that there weren’t more songs that took advantage of it colour-wise. I like the idea of a tongue “getting purple from singing the blues”. I also enjoyed the instrumentation in general, especially the atmospheric stuff that builds up at the end. That aside though, I was pretty immediately uncomfortable with some of your lyrical choices, and unfortunately that kept up throughout the whole song. Reading the bio you wrote, it seems like you’re trying to come from a place of sincerity, but the “comedy” lyrics just completely undermine it. I understand there’s a history of this kind of casual sexism in blues lyrics, and it continues to be really disappointing to me. It’s entirely possible to make a “woe is me” song without deliberately alienating at least half the population. There’s 32 official entries this round, and as far as I can tell, a grand total of three of them feature female musicians. Five if you count the shadows from myself and Also in Blue. As a woman, if I was interested in participating in something like Spintunes and happened to click on this song before anything else, I probably wouldn’t enter because I wouldn’t feel welcome, and that’s a real problem in music as a whole. I don’t like constantly pointing out obvious stuff like this to guys, but hopefully talking about it blatantly helps make a difference. I’m very interested to hear what the other (male) judges say about this song.
The Brewhouse Sessions - #FFC0CB
This was the first song of the lot that I found myself doing some actual toe-tapping, so good  work on that front! This is a really fun song and I thoroughly enjoyed it from start to end. I’m a  big fan of pink in general, and I’m really pleased there was at least one song celebrating it. It  immediately made me think of this amazing pink Cadillac that would often drive down Brunswick  St in Fitzroy when I lived in Australia. This is a pretty light and fluffy song, but it has just the right  level of flamboyance; all it’s missing is some Lou Reed-esque shoop-a-dooping background  singers (think Satellite of Love style à la Transformer). 
Cavedwellers - Chartreuse To me, this song is exactly like an 80s romance novel in musical form. It’s been driving me absolutely bananas, because I know this melody already but it’s been a long time and I just can’t place it. I really like the tone of those rhythmic guitars in the left channel. Overall this is very well done, and it’s grown on me as I’ve listened, but I just can’t shake the idea that I know it from somewhere else. I’d also cut that last little guitar solo and end it at 2:53.
Jealous Brother - Lemon Tangerine (#FREEBRITNEY) 
This song is super enjoyable without understanding any of the context, but it really does hit well  when you know the backstory. I’m only recently familiar with the Britney saga, so my knowledge  of the facts is pretty basic, but even with that I was able to follow along with the main ideas and  themes pretty well. Your lyrics scanned a little oddly when I read them, but when listening, they fit really well with the melody. Musically this is just an absolute bop and I’ve really enjoyed  listening to it every time. Everything is super tight and I love the little false ending. 
Brian Gray - Purple Dot / Something Like Home 
This was an immediate favourite and I’m looking forward to an entire musical, pretty please.  Excellent opening line to set the scene. Your visual storytelling is absolutely spot-on. All the lines  are very economical, telling as much story with as few words as possible. I’d just finished  reading Andy Weir’s book ‘Project Hail Mary’ the night before all the songs landed, and your  lyrics had some overlap with that story, although to be honest, while I enjoyed that book, this  song is much better! The “touchdown” section is very reminiscent musically of the song ‘Quiet’  from Matilda. That could just be due to the conventions of writing for musicals, but that song  specifically was one that came to mind straight away (I love that song and have listened to it, oh  my, a lot of times). The way you build tension throughout the song is fantastically enjoyable, and  you’re really very good at emoting through your vocal delivery. The way you sing “everything is  so insanely purple”, for example, is just full of wonder. My favourite lyric of the whole saga is  “Onward! 30 billion tattoos of a Songbird sing of hope for bringing out the Best in you, achieving  what you’re manifestly Destined to instead of merely coming out alive.” This was an early  frontrunner for my number one spot. Really, really, really good work. 
Good Guy Sôjàbé - Grey 
The atmospheric sounds you’ve got going on throughout this song are very cool. This song is  unfortunately one of those one’s that just slips through my consciousness. It’s like the movie ‘Heat’, where it’s very well made and a lot of people really love it, and I’ve seen it several times, but couldn’t describe anything from it to save myself. I think the issue that I’m having with this  and several of the other “grey” songs is that you’ve matched the music to the colour just too  literally. It’s all very monotone, and as a result, isn’t particularly memorable for me. 
Jocko Homomorphism - Eigengrau 
Of all the songs this round, I think you’ve managed to be the most inventive with the challenge. I  hadn’t heard of “eigengrau” before this, but even without knowing the names and the theories,  it’s something that is pretty universal and instinctively easy to understand. “Eigengrau is old as  time” is probably my favourite line, and your lyrical storytelling in general is just very strong here.  The squeal-y sounds and their subtle shifts each time are a highlight, as is the way the song  kind of disintegrates at the end. 
Phlubububub - Indigo 
There have been a few songs with this 60s/70s flower power vibe this round. I wonder if it’s a bit  of a trend that’s happening in general currently. I like that yours has that hippy vibe, but that it’s  disrupted by the technology mentioned (CDs), grabbing the whole song and shifting it out of  time. Speaking of time, the way it shifts around did feel a little awkward on the first couple of  listens, but started to feel quite natural after a few runs through. The problem is that the rest of  the song is a little too monotone and drifty to sustain a lot of interest for me, so if I didn’t need to  listen to it several times through for judging, I probably wouldn’t have given it the attention that it  needs. Lyrically, just reading the lyrics, they’re a little awkward. I don’t know if I’m feeling that  way because I make visual art and so I’m not able to be objective regarding the subject matter,  like when you watch someone acting on TV trying to do an activity that you’re very familiar with,  or if it’s something else. 
Menage a Tune - Disco Silver 
I love disco. The music is full of energy and it’s a super fun song. I like a lot of the imagery in the  lyrics, and when the layered vocals come in things get more interesting. There’s one thing  holding the song back though, and that’s the processing, or lack thereof, on the vocals. I can  imagine that you may have been going for a dichotomy with the lyrical approach and song style,  but with disco, you really just need to go all in. Along with just some general timing nudges, the  vocals need EQing, then compression, compression and more compression. Then some reverb  and saturation to really bed them into the track and add atmosphere. And maybe some more  compression. You could also consider layering in some background vocals and doubles to really  bring the whole thing home. While it’s not strictly disco, one album that I’d really recommend  listening to if you want to make more music in this vein is ‘Impossible Princess’ by Kylie  Minogue. I look forward to hearing what you’ll do with your songs in the rest of the competition. 
Third Cat - Green Machine 
I wrote some notes for this on the plane, and I think it must have been somewhere near the end  of the trip because they make absolutely no sense whatsoever. And I quote: “Nice moves from  blue to green machine. Cool movement in sounds. Feels light in general. Comes & goes.” I think 
what I meant by that is I quite enjoyed it while listening, but there’s not a lot of substance in  there, either lyrically or musically, to really grip me.  
Ross Durand - Ultimate Gray First up, I really appreciate the way that you built the song musically. It’s not something I would have realised without you explaining it, which is totally fine imo, but I always enjoy when people find an interesting way to technically structure their songs. Secondly, this colour reminds me a lot of one of my “favourites” discovered last year, “Perfectly Greige”. Down to the song though, I think I have a couple of stumbling blocks with it, one being that musically it’s suffering from the monochrome syndrome that I’m also feeling with the other songs about grey: the colour itself is uninteresting, and the feel of the music is just matched too closely to the colour, and as a result, I’m not finding that particularly interesting either. I think part of it with this song is that you’re just writing about something you’ve just chosen at random that you really don’t care about, and it shows. A couple of things that stick out musically that just aren’t for me are that cymbal sound mixed on the left and the little false ending that happens before the last chorus. I don’t think the song needs that last chorus and you could just cut it and finish quite happily at 2:02.
New Fangled Trolleys - Yellow Stickey Notes 
It’s pretty clever to choose a colour that is immediately able to be perfectly visualised by most  people, especially one that even people with visual impairments can viscerally understand. This  song is pretty fun, the lyrics are strong, and your voice is very expressive and suited well to the  genre. I do have a stumbling block with this song though, and it’s a similar one to all the songs  about grey: you’ve deliberately matched the structure of the song to the idea of endless  monotony, and as a result, the song starts feeling long and monotonous. Even though it’s not a  particularly long song, it starts to feel quite long after [purposeful dissonance…..] when you go  back in to “got my yellow notes on my yellow pad”. I think you could cut some of those final  sections entirely and still paint a picture of uncut dreariness without the song itself feeling like  it’s outstayed its welcome. 
Lichen Throat - Silver Elite 
Gotta say, that opening tone is pretty discombobulating when you’re actually listening on a  plane. I automatically looked up at the seatbelt sign. Subject matter wise, I’ve never really  understood the obsession with frequent flyer miles. They do exist outside the USA, but the level  of discussion that I see from Americans just isn’t there in any of the places that I’ve lived. As a  result, I find it difficult to connect with this song on a lyrical or thematic level. Musically I really  quite enjoyed the composition, and that dark Joy Division-y feel. A couple of rhythmic changes  that I’d suggest to improve the flow of the vocals would be to pause for a couple of beats in  specific spots. For example, “But I spend my share of time in (pause for a beat) planes and  cars”. Paying attention to little moments like that throughout the whole song would go a long  way in helping it feel a little more cohesive. I enjoyed the little change in melody for the bridge  section. 
Temnere - 1493
Really excellent theatrical storytelling here. While musically it never goes anywhere that I don’t  expect, it plays to the genre very well, and is so action packed that the predictability doesn’t  matter so much. I was flying over a Spanish mountain range when this one came on, which  made the whole thing feel extra dramatic. My favourite little bit in the mix is when you  occasionally pan a handful of the drums to mimic the sounds of marching through the night; it’s  helps create a really nice mental picture. One other mix note: there seems to be some kind of  masking happening with another track every time you sing “heroes”, which to my ear makes it  sound like you’re singing “D-eeroes”. Good work though; I don’t normally listed to this type of  song and really enjoyed this overall. 
Jim of Seattle - Gray 
This one was an immediate front-runner for me from the first listen. The lyrics are incredibly  clever, and stylistically it’s the only one of the “grey” songs to break out of a monotone delivery.  The retro vibes and upbeat feel are right up my alley, and the backing vocals in particular are  really lovely. I could have sworn that you’re singing “boranger” when you’re actually singing  “more angelic”; I had to go back and listen to that while following the lyrics as written to hear it  as “more angelic”. I kinda wish it was “boranger”, because that particular mondegreen gave me  a big laugh. On a slightly fussy note, in the written lyrics, I wish you hadn’t broken up words that  run over two bars with a hyphen and line break; it’s probably a useful technique for you when  you’re writing, but I don’t need the exact breakdown of where every rhyme falls and would rather  just being able to read it through straight. On a slightly personal note, my hair went silver long  before I started getting old (thanks genetics), I like eating super-tart green apples, and I spell  grey with an E”, so those lines all hit me in a different way than they would most people. My  personal favourite line of the whole song is “The sweet surprise of that particular note”. Good  job overall, this is an excellent song. 
galoshy - Blue 
This is a beautiful follow up to Jim’s uptempo song. I really enjoyed the opening section a lot,  and kind of wish it had stayed at that pace throughout the whole song. When you changed it up  musically at “do you have little time”, I lost a bit of interest and found it difficult to pay attention.  The whole thing has some strong Nick Drake vibes and is overall pretty enjoyable, but it didn’t  live up to my expectations from that excellent opening. 
“BucketHat” Bobby Matheson - Seeing Mauve (Rose-Coloured Glasses) 
“Your smile stretches for miles, don’t you think that’s a little much?” Is a fantastic opening line.  It’s lighthearted and sets a good tone, but unfortunately the rest of the lyrics devolved into  something that I found bordering on too mean. Reading your notes, I think it’s a fun idea to write  to live input and participation from audience members, but it can also be an Achilles heel  because it make editing judiciously less likely. On the whole, the lyrics end up feeling incredibly  mansplainy to me, for five and a half minutes. It’s way too long and bitter. This song could be  improved drastically in a couple of ways. The first thing I’d do is change the perspective: make  the “you” a “he”, for example, and you lose some of the mansplaining feel, as well as making the  listener feel more welcome in general. As it is with the “you”, it *feels* like you’re dissing me  directly, and no listener wants to be told that they’re wrong or shit. Musically I’d increase the tempo just so it feels a little more bouncy, and I’d just cut some verses entirely because there’s  too many of them just saying the same thing over and over using different words. I do hope you  keep working on it because there’s the heart of a really good song in there. 
Boffo Yux Dudes - Green With Envy 
I thoroughly enjoyed this song, and it’s probably my favourite Boffo Yux Dudes song that I’ve  heard so far. It’s a great length and feels nice and bouncy the whole way through. I don’t love  the phrase “not a good look” in general, but it works for the rhyme at least. I do really like the  
line “A burst of enveloping prismatic light”, and the lyrics flow well in general. Mix wise the  compression feels a bit overcooked, but that’s an easy fix. Good job! 
Sober - Kintsugi 
You should write songs quickly more often. I get the impression that you have a tendency for  perfectionism, and the reason that this song works so well is that it hasn’t been overworked  musically or lyrically. This is also reflected nicely in the idea of Kintsugi: that things don’t need to  be perfect to have value, and sometimes the imperfections are what make things interesting and  worthwhile. I’m guessing you’ve chosen the particular instrumentation because it’s what you  probably enjoy the most, but there’s a lovely parallel between the way these instruments are  played and Kintsugi. The lines those instruments play underneath the vocals almost feel like  little rivers of gold holding the song together. One small change I’d make would be to add a  couple of beats after that low note to just let the song breathe for a second. As it is, that  particular moment feels a little rushed and crowded. Really good work though. This is one of my  favourites from you. 
Brother Baker - Cobalt, and Fading 
I’m not familiar with the band you’ve mentioned in your notes, but to me this has a real 90s  Dinosaur Jr vibe. I do instinctively enjoy this type of sound and style, and in particular I really  liked the piano part, but for some reason this song did take quite a few listens for me to even  really register what the lyrics are, and I had to read them to figure out the themes. It’s not that  they’re buried or unclear at all; I think it’s more to do with the song being All On All The Time.  There’s not a moment of respite to think, and the whole thing just kept washing over me. Like,  you know, I long for vibrance, but I just can’t find it. It feels like cobalt with no warmth. (Sorry.) I  guess what I’m saying is it’s successful in that it does what it says on the tin, but it just doesn’t  hit home for me personally. 
The Pleasantry - Rosé 
I didn’t really like this song on the first listen, but it did grow on me subsequentlyt. I like that it’s  completely different from everything else this round, and I enjoy those glitchy beats and sounds  a lot. Cybronica’s background vocal fit really well in particular. I didn’t like the lyrics though. It  comes across to me like you’re going for humour, but it very much sounds like you’re punching  down a bit, like you’re being just a bit too mean and stereotypical about the type of people these  characters that you’re playing are based on. It feels weird saying this on one of the few songs  that features a woman, but like a couple of the other songs this round, I feel like there’s some heavy duty mansplaining happening lyrically. I think you’re probably aware of that, but overall  the perspective that frames the song makes it feel a bit thoughtless. 
thanks, brain - Bleed Out Purple 
There are things that I really like about this song and other parts that just kind of wash over me  indiscriminately. I was never able to really grasp what it’s about at all, either when listening or  even when reading through the lyrics. With some songs that’s not a problem, but this one left  me a little cold and I feel like some more solid clues as to what it’s about would help. I enjoyed  the samples and there’s a nice level of musical tension coming across. I also really like that  abrupt ending. The mix could use a few little touches (maybe some saturation or bussing a  single reverb to everything) to glue the different instruments together a bit more substantially  and bed everything down. Overall I enjoyed this, but it wasn’t particularly memorable, which is  unfortunate in a such a large group of songs. 
Hot Pink Halo - Clementine (SHADOW) 
It me. I didn’t really have time to do write a song this time around, but have wanted to write a  blues and couldn’t really resist a colour challenge. This is a song about how much I love my  guitar, which is bright orange with red racing stripes. It’s the ultimate immediate-make-feel gooder machine. 
Also in Blue - Shadow Grey (SHADOW) This is beautiful. I love everything about it. As someone with an overly acute sense of colour perception alongside a career in art and design, colour blindness is something I think about fairly often, but can never really understand at anything other than a theoretical level. Somehow switching the senses and listening to descriptions instead of reading about them, especially in this stripped-back a cappella style, allows me to build a clearer picture and a better understanding of how it might feel to be colourblind. Plus your wife can sing really well. Good job all round. I love that out of all the judges, the two of us with a colour in our band names were the ones to submit songs. :)

Thank you for your review! I think you picked up on something most people did not;
ReplyDeleteMy submission was somewhat intentionally directional; the listener, the subject of the song, the wearer of the rose coloured glasses, is actually more based on myself. I do not really relate to the narrator in this song in any way. If you feel attacked by this song, you get it. You are experiencing the emotion I meant to underline. It worked.
The song is my way of mocking the people who have mocked me for my “excessive optimism”.
It’s interesting you picked up on “mansplainey”.
While I identify myself more as the subject of the song than the narrator, I decided to swap the gender of the subject in question to a woman. This simultaneously helped me to separate myself from the subject and create a slightly more familiar narrative. Mansplainey was actually one of the descriptions in my head while writing.
But I don’t think I actually wrote anything that confirms the genders of either character. So, it’s really interesting and cool to me that you picked up on that.
Hey Bobby, thanks for the response. I was sort of surprised that no one else picked up on it, but sadly also sort of unsurprised, because all the other reviewers are male. I've found that women notice this type of situation/language more often than men because it's generally much more common for us. I suspected that it was a role reversal type situation in the lyrics, but I still think that it would have worked better if it wasn't in First Person, because although you wrote it from your point of view, that context is removed for your listeners and they hear the "you" as directed at them.
DeleteThanks for the comment about splitting lines mid-word. I've seen that done many times in lyric sheets for Broadway cast albums that split a word across two lines like that, so I felt like it was the "correct" way to do it, but given the fact that I was kind of trying to bury those bridge rhymes and try not to draw attention to them, I should have printed the lyrics out in a way that would also bury them. Kicking myself now.
ReplyDeleteHey Jim, no worries. It was no big deal, just a personal preference, so no need to kick yourself! :)
Delete