If you missed the Bonus Round Listening Party, never fear! You can hear all ten Bonus Round covers and re-imaginings, in glorious stereo sound, on Bandcamp or embedded below. Enjoy!
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
Monday, May 5, 2025
ST24 Round 4 Results
The results are in, and we have a champion! Amid four great Final Round songs (and a batch of excellent shadow entries too!), the techno-skeptical lament "Vulpes Vulpes" won over both the contestants and the judges. Congratulations to first-time participant Vehicles of Beware, who earns the title of SpinTunes 24 Champion!
The next two competitors were tied in the contestants' vote, so I turned to the judges for the tie-breaker. By just one point, David Taro earns second place, followed by Governing Dynamics in third. Celestial Drift comes in fourth place among our four excellent Final Round songs.
Read on for the full breakdown of contestants' and judges' votes!
ST24.4 Reviews - glennny
Read on for Round 4 reviews from SpinTunes 23 Champion glennny:
Celestial Drift- Water Fox
Swampy! I love the vibe. There are some killer riffs here. The vocal melody falls short for me. It reminds me of Les Claypool, the way it’s a character voice telling a story. This is fun, and it may be too short. I don’t think the solo develops into its potential. There’s a super dirty groove here, and I desperately want to take a 24-bar slide solo on this song. The lyrics are solid. Well done!
Vehicles of Beware- Vulpes Vulpes
This is my favorite of the round. I did not expect the drum machine, it’s interesting and cool. The best part is the acoustic guitar. It sounds great. There’s something very Sting about the chorus. It reminds me of Mad About You or something like that. Maybe the best part is the heavy riff? So much good stuff all over this track. Your voice is awesome! The passionate “we didn’t see it coming” is awesome! I’m quite excited for your future songs! Great job!
David Taro- Kitsune
You win the production fight. I’m in awe. Every instrument sounds so perfect. Do the toms have their own microphone? They sound so good. All of the little touches are quite beautiful. The dynamics of this are amazing. This listen really shines with headphones. I think this is too long. I think it would’ve been stronger edited down.
Governing Dynamics-Blue Ruin
I finally like where you placed the vocals in the mix. The drum machine is cool. A bit of a strange choice, perhaps an easier animal to control? I think I would cut the pre-choruses. There’s not much of a dynamic lift between them and the chorus. There are so many lyrics. Not enough instrumental interludes, be they solos or breaks. All that said, I really enjoy the listen.
Joy Sitler- Survival of the Fittest
This is wonderful! I’m a fan! I’ve been enjoying My Broken Demo tape on Spotify in non-contest world. How do you pack so much song in 97 seconds? It’s astounding. This is a great song! The lyrics are clever, they remind me of Stephin Merritt (high praise, easily my favorite lyricist)
Jealous Brother- Lost in the Fog
This is a sweet folky tune. Oh man, that acoustic guitar solo is so tasty! I love the music-to-vocal ratio of this song. The brushed snare is perfect. All of the jam band folks I talk concerts with would love this song. Excellent job! Vocals, melody, and performance are all top notch!
Hot Pink Halo- Textboom Case
See you in Song Fight! I didn’t read the title, Geech read it to me. I wrote on our fakebook whiteboard “Text Bookcase”. There are some tasty bass lines going on in this thing. A lot of the vocal phrasing sounds awkward to me. This is fun enough.
Sober- from This Clay
Always a delight to hear you play. The vocals and harmonies are exquisite. Damn! Do have other players that could play this song with you? Such badass playing! I love the acoustic, the mandolin, the banjo. This is world-class. Wow! I don’t understand how you’re not in the finals. This song is a really good one for you. If I were at a listening booth in the 80’s, you would have sold me on this album. Excellent!
TBOES-of droughts and flooding rains
Rock power! I love this side of you Gizo! Vocals are just awesome. I do think the loud guitars are a bit quiet in the mix. It’s a punk song. The angst is at 10, Very cool drums in this. I love it!
ST24 Bonus Round Listening Party and Champion Announcement
The Final Round voting period has closed, and a SpinTunes 24 Champion has been chosen. But who is it? Find out at tonight's Listening Party, hosted at 10 pm EDT (note the later time!) by Tommy G.
Before the Champion is revealed, Tommy G will play the Bonus Round covers we've received - seven so far! Remember that the Bonus Round deadline is flexible, so if you're still working on a cover version of a SpinTunes 24 entry, send it in when it's finished!
Join us at 10 pm EDT on YouTube or embedded below.
Tuesday, April 29, 2025
ST24 Round 4 Album
If you missed last night's Listening Party, never fear: the SpinTunes 24 Round 4 album is available to download or stream on Bandcamp or embedded below.
Take a listen, and remember that if you competed in Round 1 but not Round 4, you'll have a chance to vote and determine the SpinTunes 24 Champion! You'll receive voting instructions later this week by email.
Monday, April 28, 2025
ST24.4 Listening Party and Contestant Voting/Bonus Round Reminder
The Round 4 deadline has passed, and we have received submissions from all four of our finalists, in addition to five shadow songs, all inspired in some way by Madeline Owen's painting Water Fox. Your first chance to hear all nine songs is at tonight's Listening Party at 8 pm EDT, hosted by Tommy G. Join us on YouTube or embedded below!
Contestant Voting
If you competed in SpinTunes 24 and you're not competing in the Final Round - you are a Final Round judge! Your votes will determine who claims the title of SpinTunes 24 Champion. You'll receive an email later this week with instructions to cast your ballot, with a deadline of Sunday, May 4 at 11:59 pm EDT. In the meantime...
Bonus Round
...now begins the Bonus Round, an optional, non-competitive round in which you're invited to submit a cover version of someone else's SpinTunes 24 song. Whether it was a competing entry or a shadow, if you heard a song in this tournament that you loved and want to put your own spin on, record it this week and send it in! Since this is a friendly, non-competitive round, your flexible deadline is next Monday when Tommy G hosts our Bonus Round Listening Party and reveals the identity of the SpinTunes 24 Champion!
Sunday, April 20, 2025
ST24.3 Reviews and Rankings - truth
Here are your rankings from SpinTunes 23 Champion truth:
Read on for truth's reviews!
ST24.3 Results
The judges have weighed in on Round 3, and their rankings have determined who will be competing in the Final Round.
This was a tough round to judge, but one entry rose quickly to the top of the list. With first place rankings from three of the five judges, David Taro claims his first SpinTunes round victory with his hooky in-and-out-of-love song "Don't You Want Me Anymore".
Two songs are tied for second place - Governing Dynamics and Vehicles of Beware scored equally in the judges' aggregate rankings. And finally, just a few points behind them in fourth place is Celestial Drift to round out the Final Round competitors.
As for the rest of our competitors - the shadow reinstatement rule is still in effect, and you've got a super cool painting to inspire you, so I hope we hear lots of shadow entries in the Final Round!
Read on for the full Round 3 results!
ST24.3 Reviews and Rankings - Valerie Polichar
Here are your rankings from Valerie Polichar:
Read on for Valerie's reviews!
ST24.3 Reviews and Rankings - Ethan Ivey
Here are your rankings from Ethan Ivey:
Read on for Ethan's reviews!
ST24.3 Reviews and Rankings - glennny
Here are your rankings from SpinTunes 23 Champion glennny:
Read on for glennny's reviews!
ST24.3 Reviews and Rankings - Jim of Seattle
Here are your rankings from Jim of Seattle:
Read on for Jim's reviews!
ST24.3 Reviews - Micah Sommersmith
I know this challenge caused some consternation among some contestants, but the goal was not to frustrate you, cause you to panic, or even to make you work at writing a good song despite the challenge; the goal was for you to use the challenge to make a good song - to think about melody deliberately, and experiment with ways of creating compelling melodies that you might not have thought of otherwise. And you know what? Many of you did so, and succeeded! This is a great batch of songs and I’m glad I don’t have to rank them against each other. Let’s dive right in!
Saturday, April 19, 2025
SpinTunes 24 Round 4 Challenge
The fourth and final challenge of SpinTunes 24 is here. This is the round that will give us our SpinTunes 24 Champion, who will be chosen by their fellow SpinTunes 24 competitors. So if you've already been eliminated from competition, you're a judge this time around!
Read on for your Final Round challenge:
Tuesday, April 15, 2025
ST24 Round 3 Album
Did you miss last night's Listening Party? Never fear - the full Round 3 album, with cover art by Matt "Shoobs" Schubbe, is now available to stream or download on Bandcamp or embedded below. Enjoy!
Monday, April 14, 2025
ST24.3 Listening Party and Deadline News
The Round 3 deadline has passed, and congratulations to our 12 contestants who all made the deadline! We also received two shadow entries.
Your first chance to hear all 14 songs is at tonight's Listening Party, hosted by Tommy G at 8 pm EDT. Join us on YouTube or embedded below:
Sunday, April 6, 2025
ST24 Round 2 Album
The Round 2 album has been reordered and is available to stream or download on Bandcamp or embedded below. As always, our faithful graphic designer Matt "Shoobs" Schubbe provides cover art. This is a fantastic collection of songs, so give it a listen if you haven't already!
ST24 Round 2 Results
The judges have made their decisions, and Round 2 of SpinTunes 24 is in the books. When you look at the full table, you might notice the wide discrepancy between rankings, and you might think to yourself, "These judges can't agree on anything!"
But in fact, the differences in rankings actually reveal something that all the judges do agree on, which is that this is an incredibly good batch of songs. The overall level of quality meant the judges had to consider small technical details, interpretation of the open-ended challenge, and their own personal preferences - all of which meant that a song that everyone agreed was enjoyable could (and often did) land near the top of one judge's rankings and the bottom of another's. That's why we've got five of them!
There were a handful of songs, though, that rose to the top of the rankings. After a second-place finish in Round 2, Vehicles of Beware charmed the judges with their gentle, world-weary tale of a traveling musician's life; "Getting to the gig" wins the round!
Sober lands in a very close second place; then at the top of a group of very similarly-scoring entrants are our tied third place finishers: Celestial Drift and Hot Pink Halo.
Read on for the full Round 2 results!
ST24.2 Reviews and Rankings - Ethan Ivey
Here are your rankings from Ethan Ivey:
Read on for Ethan's reviews!
ST24.2 Reviews and Rankings - glennny
Here are your rankings from SpinTunes 23 Champion glennny:
Read on for glennny's reviews!
ST24.2 Reviews and Rankings - Jim of Seattle
Here are your rankings from Jim of Seattle:
Read on for Jim's reviews!
ST24.2 Reviews and Rankings - Truth
Here are your rankings from SpinTunes 23 Champion Truth:
Read on for Truth's reviews!
ST24.2 Reviews and Rankings - Valerie Polichar
Here are your rankings from Valerie Polichar:
Read on for Valerie's reviews!
Saturday, April 5, 2025
ST24 Round 3 Challenge
Here we are, halfway though SpinTunes 24. The judges are still finalizing their Round 2 rankings and reviews, but they loved how the Round 2 challenge pushed you to think about the rhythmic aspect of melody and song structure, and they loved hearing the terrific songs that resulted. So we're going to stay in that general area, and see how you do with another melody-focused challenge.
Read on for your Round 3 challenge:
Monday, March 31, 2025
ST24.2 Listening Party and Deadline News
The Round 2 deadline has passed. 17 of 21 Round 2 contestants submitted by the deadline, leaving 4 open spots for shadow reinstatements. As it happens, we also received exactly 4 eligible shadows. Welcome back to the competition, Möbius Strip Club, We Happy Few, Celestial Drift, and Hot Pink Halo!
We also received two shadows that were ineligible for reinstatement, for a total of 23 songs. Your first chance to hear all 23 songs is at tonight's Listening Party hosted by Tommy G at 8 pm EDT. Join us on YouTube or embedded below!
Sunday, March 23, 2025
ST24 Round 1 Results
Round 1 of SpinTunes 24 is in the books, and a great round it was. Amid a very strong field of thirty entries, a recent SpinTunes champion slid back into the competition and earned a top-five placement from every judge, putting him comfortably at the top of the heap. Congratulations to our Round 1 winner, Tunes By LJ!
Another previous SpinTunes champion, Flintsteel (né Temnere) earns the points for a second place finish, but is tied with a SpinTunes newcomer, Vehicles of Beware. There's room for both of them on that side of the podium, leaving the third place spot vacant.
Read on for the full Round 1 results!
ST24.1 Reviews and Rankings - Ethan Ivey
Here are your rankings from Ethan Ivey:
Read on for Ethan's reviews!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)