ST18.2 Results UPDATED 10/25

The results of an incredibly difficult Round 3 are in. A few entries polarized the judges, but a few stood out with consistently high rankings. At the top of the heap this round is

Sober

Rounding out the top three are Jim of Seattle in second place and "BucketHat" Bobby Matheson in third.

Rank	Artist	AiB	BotW	Chumpy	Leonie	Ryan	Total
1	Sober	7	1	5	6	5	24
2	Jim of Seattle	1	4	1	17	4	27
3	"BucketHat" Bobby Matheson	5	6	2	5	12	30
4	Cavedwellers	12	13	7	1	2	35
5	Chas Rock	4	5	12	4	14	39
5	Daniel Sitler	10	3	6	14	6	39
7	Stacking Theory	16	9	4	3	9	41
8	Phlubububub	3	2	19	2	18	44
9	Brian Gray	18	7	8	9	3	45
10	New Fangled Trolleys	2	21	3	21	1	48
11	See-Man-Ski	6	8	16	7	16	53
12	Third Cat	9	16	9	8	15	57
13	The Dutch Widows	13	10	17	10	8	58
14	Governing Dynamics	11	15	10	11	11	58
15	Brother Baker	8	12	15	15	10	60
16	Sara Parsons	17	18	11	12	7	65
17	Jocko Homomorphism	15	11	18	13	13	70
18	Temnere	14	14	14	16	17	75
19	Jealous Brother	20	17	13	18	19	87
20	The Brewhouse Sessions	19	20	21	19	20	99
21	Timothy Patrick Hinkle	21	19	20	20	21	101
22	Menage a Tune	22	22	22	22	22	110

There were a cluster of entries with very close scores around the elimination threshold; in fact, The Dutch Widows and Governing Dynamics tied each other right on the threshold. Since The Dutch Widows scored higher than Governing Dynamcs with 3 out of 5 judges and also submitted their entry earlier, I've chosen them to move on to Round 3. 

UPDATE: A discrepancy was noticed between one of the judges' scores as posted on the spreadsheet vs. on the judge's reviews post. The spreadsheet had Governing Dynamics and The Dutch Widows tied straddling the elimination threshold, whereas using the rankings from the review post would send both to the next round and eliminate Third Cat instead. Instead, all three will be moving on to the next round.

Therefore, the following entrants have scored below the elimination cutoff and have been eliminated:

Brother Baker, Sara Parsons, Jocko Homomorphism, Temnere, Jealous Brother, The Brewhouse Sessions, Timothy Patrick Hinkle, Menage a Tune 

With 14 eligible entrants instead of the planned 13, a single entrant missing the deadline will not result in a shadow reinstatement. Multiple entrants missing the deadline will result in one fewer shadow reinstatement, to bring the total back to 13. (For example, if 3 official entrants miss the deadline, 2 shadows are eligible for reinstatement.)

Now for individual judges' full reviews and rankings:

• Also in Blue's reviews and rankings
• Boy on the Wall's reviews and rankings
• Chumpy and Ryan's reviews and rankings
• Leonie's reviews and rankings
• Contestant Chas Rock's reviews
• Micah's reviews